vilaine fille had the good fortune to attend three high-profile musical events last week. Thursday night brought stunning sets at Birdland by the pianist Enrico Pieranunzi, in trio with Marc Johnson and Paul Motian, and the trumpeter Enrico Rava, in a quintet that included the brilliant young trombone virtuoso Gianluca Petrella.
I was struck almost dumb by Rava’s austere but intense music-making and his mind-boggling virtuosity. Ribbons of supple, buttery tone, blistering squeaks, filthy shreds, long, downy-soft sighs… Is there no sound that Rava cannot draw from a horn? And, G-d, is he sexy—also sweet, gentle, and not nearly so diabolico up close as he appears on stage.
Rava has a gorgeous catalogue of ECM recordings and also appears on Gianmaria Testa’s Altre latitudini. In coming days, Rava and the pianist Stefano Bollani play gigs in Chicago, Boston, and at SFJazz.
Saturday night, at Carnegie Hall, I heard the St. Louis Symphony under David Robertson play John Adams’ “On the transmigration of souls” and Brahms’ Ein deutsches Requiem. It’s hard for me to say much about the Adams—I listened to one of the recently released 9/11 recordings and spent a sleepless night afterwards. I will say that while some took issue with the fragmentary, quizzical nature of Adams’ music and its apparent lack of teleology, I am grateful for those qualities. Then again, I agree with Ron Rosenbaum when he writes, contra the so-called “Freedom Tower” project,
the best thing to do would be to preserve the gaping wound, not try to cover it up, pretty it over, gentrify it, achieve some contrived “architectural solution” to the problem.
There is no architectural solution to tragedy, to history, no architectural solution that could do justice to the truth of the event other than to leave that gaping hole in the ground.
In the Brahms, the Saint Louis Symphony Chorus under Amy Kaiser turned in some of the most wondrously mellow singing I have heard. “Selig sind die Toten,” in particular, was ravishing. The childlike, otherworldly tones of the opening measures gradually gave way to rich but translucent layers of sound—the aural equivalent of Rembrandt’s washes of amber and gold, a quality I have encountered previously only in Act II of a Scala Forza led by Riccardo Muti.
The baritone soloist was vilaine fille coqueluche Russell Braun. I thought that the part lay a bit low for him, but how beautifully he articulated the text, and what quiet fervor he brought to “Herr, lehre doch mich.” Again, I warmly commend to you Braun’s recording of Schubert’s Die Winterreise, which I chose as one of Newsday’s top CDs of 2005.
Finally, I saw Don Pasquale at the Met and would have left after the first act if I hadn’t had a Newsday review to write. Anna Netrebko is talented. She has a lovely voice, pluck, great beauty… How could she go so horribly wrong? I loathed Cecilia Bartoli’s mugging in the 1998 Met Nozze di Figaro, but Netrebko’s antics in Don Pasquale were orders of magnitude more repellent. And I thought that her Gilda earlier this season was more than respectable. (Then again, when you find yourself appreciative that a musician is bothering to fake her trills instead of omitting them altogether…)
I had planned to see Don Pasquale several times, since I am indeed High Priestess of the Most Holy Congregation of Flórez, but I think I’ll limit myself to the performance with Petrova.
Oh, let’s not end on such a down note. I leave you with one of the most sublime things I know: the serenata from Don Pasquale as sung by Tito Schipa.
Donizetti’s opera teems with in-jokes—the parody of the Lucia wedding contract scene being the most obvious one. And while waltzes dominate the last hour of Don Pasquale, as befits a “modern,” urban opera written for Paris, Donizetti opens the final act with this bit of pointedly archaic heaven, complete with an echt-pastoral moniker (“Nina”), sweetly predictable rhymes, and faux guitar-strumming. What genius it took to write something so apparently simple and so utterly bewitching!
Schipa’s performance exemplifies everything that vilaine fille prizes in singing: impeccable craft, clear enunciation, simplicity, elegance, humility, heart. Buon ascolto!
P.S. Only 13 days until Lohengrin opens!
Recent Comments