My review of the new Opera Rara recording of Donizetti’s Dom Sébastien appears in this week’s Time Out New York. The vilaine fille capsule review: Meh.
Though recorded shortly before Giuseppe Filianoti’s electrifying Met début, the performance captures neither il nostro nor the cast’s other stars (Kasarova and Keenlyside) at their best, and the opera is long and uneven.
Speaking of Don Peppino, he is still recovering from an appendectomy and a bout of peritonitis. Following his acclaimed portrayal of Werther in Rome, he was forced to withdraw from two runs of La traviata (Rome, Naples) and what was to have been his role début as Massenet’s Des Grieux (Palermo). vilaine fille sends Filianoti tanti auguri di pronta guarigione. As of right now, he is still scheduled to take on the title role of Rossini’s Otello (opposite the Rodrigo of Juan Diego Flórez) at the Rossini Opera Festival.
I saw La Vie en Rose. As a film, it strikes me as a great churning bucket of slop—bloated, poorly constructed, and beyond mawkish. At one point, the child Edith hears Saint Thérèse of Lisieux speaking to her from what appears to be a cloud of Tinker Bell’s fairy dust.
That’s the kind of scene that usually sends vilaine fille rushing for the exit. Still, for all its flaws, La Vie en Rose is a must-see. Tetsuo Nagata’s cinematography is sumptuous, lush and velvety like an overripe rose, while the costumes (by Marit Allen) and the sets and art direction (credits here) are equally remarkable.
And while Olivier Dahan, bless his heart, did a poor job constructing his film, he drew superb work from his cast. Everything you have heard and read about Marion Cotillard is true—and then some. Her searing, titanic portrayal of Piaf shook me to my core. The girls who play Piaf as a child, Manon Chevallier and Pauline Burlet, are also heartbreakers. Even Depardieu (who has tended to coast in recent years, soyons francs) turns in a sober, finely wrought performance.
A 20-CD set advertising itself as Edith Piaf L’Intégrale 2007 can be had for around USD 50. It offers no documentation or notes, but it’s admirably compact, the transfers are good, and—wow!—is that ever bang for the buck. Though no expert in Piaf lore, I’m guessing that the set is not really an intégrale, because chez les grenouilles (je vous adore, mes poules !), that term often means: Everything—except the stuff we left out! (I own, and cherish, L’Intégrale des disques Vogue by Françoise Hardy, but find new-to-me Vogue Hardy recordings nearly every time I look elsewhere.) On the other hand, 413 Piaf songs will keep anyone busy for a good long time.
There’s an abundance of Piaf material on YouTube. And in case you’re away from your discs and files, here’s a little GoEar playlist:
Tu es partout (1941)
Y a pas de printemps (1944)
Hymne à l’amour (1949)
Sous le ciel de Paris (1954)
Mon Dieu (1960)
Recent Comments